The
couple of Sherman III kits I’ve bought to represent vehicles
used in Normandy, didn’t have the decals I wanted. Sadly the
kit makers apparently neglect the French summer of 1944. So I bought
this set dedicated to vehicles seen on Gold beach on D-Day. It is
printed for 1/76 vehicles, but the difference being very little (about
5%) the markings can also be used for 1/72 scale models. It is a mixed
set with generic markings and some specific vehicles.
The generic part gives markings [unit badge and Arms of Service (AoS)]
for eight 8th Armoured Brigade (AB) vehicles, four 2nd CLY 79th Armoured
Division (AB) vehicles and four 6th Assault Regiment 79th AD vehicles.
The specific vehicles are five 8th AB Sherman tanks, a 31st AB Churchill
tank, a 50th Infantry Division (ID) Humber utility vehicle, a 50th
ID universal carrier and a 50th ID ambulance (although the last two
don’t have a WD number or a specific marking, Mr. Dan Taylor
wrote me they correctly depict two photographed vehicles plausibly
repainted in SCC15).
|
|
|
|
--- |
About
the 8th AB tanks, their markings are the correct combined divisional
badge/AoS typical of this Brigade. The AoS numbers supplied are the
993 (Brigade HQ), the 994 (4/7 Dragoons), the 995 (24 Lancers), the
996 (Sherwood Rangers Yeomanry) and the 475 (12th Kings Royal Rifle
Corp). They can be used not only for the Sherman tanks: the recce troops
had Stuarts Mk III and the Motor Battalion had Half Tracks, Universal
Carriers, Loyd Carriers and some trucks.
Anyway what I found about the specific tanks not always matches the
set instructions. Basing on the very few photos of them I’ve seen
here following are the points where I found some differences: |
Mk
V T147308, 8th Bde HQ VIRGIN.
The markings are correct as depicted, but the original tank was a
Mk III.
|
|
Mk
Vc T148496, 24 Lancers A Sqn.
Correct as depicted [IWM B5416], but the triangle should be also on
the rear turret bin (in the original tank photo, it is hidden by some
personal items, but it is visible on another Firefly of the same unit).
See notes below for the glacis.
|
|
Mk
I T152081, 24 Lancers HQ.
The original tank [IWM B6218] was a Mk III. I’ve found it with
the WD number reported as T152881, anyway Dan Taylor wrote me it could
be “081” with the “0” dirtied. For sure it
had the turret bin. It should have the rhomboid marking also on the
rear turret bin. See notes below for the glacis.
|
|
Mk
V ABERDEEN, 4/7 Dragoon Guards, A Sqn.
The original tank [IWM B5258] was a Sherwood Rangers Yeomanry Mk III.
In the two photos I’ve seen of it (both taken while it was coming
ashore from LCT 1076) it had the white number (52 or 62) carried forward
the A Sqn blue triangle; both markings are missing in the set. If I’ve
correctly understood the 8th AB rule, it could have had the LCT number
19009/2165 just above the right fender. See notes below for the glacis. |
|
Mk
III T146929, Sherwood Rangers Yeomanry, A Sqn AKILLA.
In the only photo I’ve seen of it [IWM B6222] the crew and the
camo net hide the turret side where it could have the blue triangle
and the white number. See notes below for the glacis. |
|
I
don’t have specific info about the 8th AB tank markings and
I’ve seen few Normandy photos of them. In these few pictures
there are some features which I think could be useful to correctly
depict an 8th AB tank in Normandy:
- The
4/7 Dragoon Guards A Sqn tanks had red and white large squared numbers
on the turret sides (see: 21 and 27 [IWM B6133] for examples). For
D-Day, B and C Squadrons had the Sherman Mk II DD with the numbers
(see: 54 and 71 [IWM B5897]) in a rounded font. As far as I’ve
found these Mk II DD didn’t have the WD numbers; they had
the US serials. Number 50 [IWM B6130], a B Sqn Mk III at the end
of June, had the same rounded font of the number already seen in
the Mk II DD and the red square in front of it. Number 5? DINGAAN
[IWM B6133], if it wasn’t again 50, is another example.
- About
the 24 Lancers: on A Sqn ARMAGEDDON and on a HQ tank the tactical
sign was also on the port side of the transmission cover, while
on the starboard side there was the combined divisional sign/AoS,
between these markings there was the name. The 24 Lancers were replaced
by 13/18 Hussars on July 29th, 1944.
- The
Sherwood Rangers Yeomanry (SRY): on the tank that follows ABERDEEN
in the landing photo the combined divisional sign/AoS is carried
on the middle of the cast transmission cover. It is the only photo
I have which shows this marking in position. I didn’t understand
the Sherwood Rangers Yeomanry numeral system: ABERDEEN, an A Sqn
tank, had 52 or 62. In other photos of anonymous tanks I’ve
seen the same unique font, like a Mk III photographed on August
1st, 1944 which had the 46 and a Mk II DD which shows the number
64 on the bustle. Due the unique font I think both were part of
the SRY. The number 47 [IWM B9749] was on a plate hanging on the
bustle of a hessian tape camouflaged Sherman Mk III turret on 28th
August 1944. B and C Sqn’s had Mk II DD’s for D-Day,
these amphibious tanks also having the US serials.
|
About
the Churchill tank:
Mk VII T252033, a Crocodile from 141st RAC.
I
don’t have a photo; however it is so listed in the MAFVA site
“Tank Names” article. It should have blue tactical signs
(possibly filled in black?) and troop numbers (sorry, I don’t
know which one). No name is given; anyway a word beginning with “S”
should be required.
|
|
For
both tank types, the witnessed use of camo nets could be useful to
hide the missing/unknown markings. About the differences I’ve
found, Mr. Dan Taylor wrote me that the next set reprints, they will
be corrected.
The
instructions suggest some particular kits, all in 1/76 scale. |
Conclusions
Overall,
I’m satisfied with this set. The majority of those points where
I feel this set is not 100% correct, can easily be solved if the manufacturer
adapts the instructions.
Yes, I also think a few tactical markings of specific tanks are missing;
anyway, the personal spare decal box or a friend could provide help
to complete our models, should someone doesn’t like the use
of hessian tapes…
Despite my remarks this set still is, in my opinion, highly recommended.
What I really found difficult (for my taste) was to find a sufficient
number of 8th AB tanks photos, taken in Normandy.
Preview
sample purchased by the author.
This
model can be purchased from
|