Being
one of the most important combat vehicles on the planet, the T-62
needs no introduction. Like many Braillers, I had griped for years
about the lack of a viable T-62 in The One True Scale. Esci had made
what they called a 1/72 T-62 years ago that was so terrible as to
be pretty much worthless. ACE made several T-62 variants that were
accurate and well-detailed, but as with most of their earlier limited-run
releases, the molding was terrible and required a lot of work or aftermarket
parts.
A few
months ago, I had built Trumpeter's SA-6 Gainful. This model had its
flaws but it looked like a SA-6, and I loved it. It featured tracks
and running gear molded in one piece, but was finely detailed and
saved a lot of build time. So when Trumpeter announced their 1/72
T-62 Model 1962, I was so overjoyed that I bought three of them. I
sat down at the bench, and two hours later had a completed model.
Though I now had a 1/72 T-62, I was no longer overjoyed.. and what
follows explains why.
Like
most of Trumpeter's 1/72 kits, the box art shows a photo of a completed
model. I say a completed model, rather than the completed model, because
the photo is of a model built from a different kit. As in Trumpeter's
1/35 T-62. That model looks very nice, and doesn't appear to have
many of the defects as the one in the box.
Hang
on, because this deception only portends the frustration to come.
|
______________
|
Suspension
The running
gear is actually very nice, with excellent detail. There are some
odd ridges and 'plates' on some of the roadwheels that can be removed
with careful sanding. The idlers and a couple of the roadwheels have
sprue attachment points that are irritating to sand off but are no
problem.
|
|
Oddly,
Trumpeter have provided the interior halves of the running gear as separate
parts; the sprocket and idler halves glue directly to the tracks, but
the interior roadwheels have to go on the suspension arms first. There
are small attachment points that have to be aligned inside the hubs.
I had to work quickly to ensure everything was aligned before the glue
dried, but it wasn't a problem.
|
|
The
track guide horns are well-done except where they touch the roadwheels;
the nice, thin guide horns give way to blocks that resemble the tracks
on S-Models kits. However, I can live with this.
|
|
The
tracks are a bit of a disappointment. They are the OMSh type, typical
of early T-62s, and the outside of the links are nicely detailed;
however, the interior side of the track links have zero detail. And
as the exterior faces of the road wheels, idlers, and sprockets are
molded onto the track runs, forget buying any aftermarket tracks unless
you also buy the entire running gear as well. You'll need to carve
the interior detail or hide them with mud. |
|
Lower
hull
The mine-clearing equipment brackets on the lower
bow are well-done, with nice bolt detail. It is missing two small
cleats, however, and there should be square holes in the two lower
plates, whereas Trumpeter has molded them flat.
|
|
The
U-shaped brackets extending from the hull sides out to above the tracks
are nicely done. |
|
The
rear hull has some weirdness going on. The details are generally well-done,
but the horns are missing. There are three small holes to the left of
the cooling fan. The instruction drawings show these holes, but don't
indicate a part to go there. The real vehicle has nothing on this part
of the rear hull, so just fill these holes in. |
|
The
external fuel drums are a disappointment.
Maddeningly, the drums are molded in halves; but even Revell does this
on their T-72, T-80s, and T-90, and I can't fault Trumpeter for molding
limitations. Revell got around the problem by molding the drums as four
parts – two for the drums themselves, and two round plates to
go on the ends. This way, you don't eat into the raised detail when
you clean up the seam.
However, Trumpeter ignored this altogether and didn't bother to even
add the raised detail to the drum ends. Moreover, the drum halves don't
align well, even with the locater pins shaved off, and the mounting
brackets and straps have no detail. |
|
Upper
Hull
Beginning at the glacis, we again see a mixed bag.
The blackout and infrared lights are well-done, but there is no headlight
guard provided!
There are no springs for the fenders, and no horns either. The fuel
tank caps on the bow are well-done, and the electrical leads, as well
as mine-clearing equipment brackets, are present.
The driver's hatch is missing a bit of electrical plumbing, but that's
an easy fix.
|
|
The
fender boxes are generally accurate, but are missing bracket and clamp
details, and again, there are no horns. |
|
And
now the most maddening feature of this kit. The turret fillet on the
real T-62 is shaped a bit like a scallop, gracefully arcing down to
the fender, with some rectangular brackets on top.
Trumpeter, for whatever reason, decided to make this a solid lump of
plastic, with sides perpendicular to the fenders rather than concave!
In order to fix this, you'd need to carve them off completely and rob
some from an ACE kit or fab your own. Hell, you might even be able to
simulate a shadow with some careful oil painting.
However, if you decide to reshape the turret fillets, you'll lose some
brackets and the molded-on spare tracks on the fender.
And again, Trumpeter knew better because part of the spares is hidden
in the incorrectly-shaped turret fillets! |
|
The
exhaust port has no detail.
The real thing had an oval-shaped opening with a rim secured by bolts.
Trumpeter has molded this as a flat piece with zero bolt detail. |
|
The
starboard fuel panniers are well-done, but have zero plumbing and are
also missing brackets and clamps. |
|
Moving
on to the engine deck, *sigh* we again have a mixed bag. The grating
texture on the grills is well-done, but inaccurate, and the grates are
missing ribs. Again, Trumpeter missed a ton of small details here.
Note also there are no tow cable parts provided.
|
|
|
Turret
The gun barrel itself is well-done, though it lacks
bolt detail on the shrouds, but the mount is very bad.
The L2G searchlight doesn't fit well onto the turret, and the connecting
arm to the main gun is non-existent in this kit, as is the plate that
connects it to the gun just forward of the canvas shroud. There's
some nice detail on the barrel here, but again, it's redundant because
there should be a part covering it! Also, there is no wiring detail
under the L2G light.
The coaxial gun is molded into its port, which I
can live with, but there is no detail around the port itself.
Some filler will be needed on top of the canvas shroud, and there
is no bolt detail on its cover plate.
|
On
the port side, there is a vision port that shows raised detail in the
instructions, but is barely visible on the kit. |
|
The
most glaring omission here is the very prominent stowage rails on
the turret sides! Granted that most modelers replace these parts with
wire anyway, but Trumpter didn't even bother to add them.
Moving
on to the upper turret, the gunner's periscope is nicely done but
appears a bit too recessed into the turret.
The radio
mount is so thick it looks more like a flagpole. Easily replaced with
stretched sprue or thin styrene rod. |
|
The
commander's hatch is nicely done, but has a solid lump of plastic
in place of an actual grab handle.
The loader's hatch likewise suffers from this failing, but is easily
corrected with wire.
Moving
down to the rear turret, the shell ejector port is nicely done, but
small details like grab handles, marker lights, and lifting horns
are non-existent.
Also there are no stowage rails on the lower part of the turret.
Note also there is no cast texture on the turret.
|
|
Decals
Decals are a series of white Soviet-style numbers, the typical Guards
symbols, and some odd white symbol.
Of course,
there is no description in the instructions of what particular vehicles
the markings represent. The decals are a bit of a let-down, as the
T-62 has seen service all across Asia, Africa, and even Cuba.
|
|
Summary
My verdict
on this kit is that it's more incomplete than inaccurate. It's not
terrible but cannot be built into a presentable T-62 out of the box.
It's light years ahead of the old Esci offering, but even the limited-run
ACE kits, with their horrible molding and unusable tracks, have some
not insignificant advantages over Trumpeter here.
I have
no background in business or the manufacturing world, but I am scratching
my head over what Trumpeter was thinking here. Were they trying to
beat ModelCollect in getting a 1/72 T-62 on the market? Did they intend
this to be a wargaming piece? Even on a wargaming piece, I would expect
to see at least the stowage rails, the presence of which just scream
Soviet armor. Trumpeter's 1/35 kit of the same vehicle is exquisite
and blows the old Tamiya offering out of the water, though, to be
fair, that's no great feat. With Trumpeter having announced the later
versions of the T-62, I won't be expecting a helluva lot from them.
If you're
looking for an accurate out-of-the-box build, I don't recommend this
kit. If you want a base to practice your scratchbuilding skills, which
honestly won't require much, then this is a great kit.
Reference
: Soviet
T-62 Main Battle Tank, by Michael D. Bishop & Patrick A. Stansell,
Grenadier Publishing, 1990
Thanks
to my friend Joel Pic for providing the kits.
This
model can be purchased from
|